I know that I have already provided a brief response to the question of homelessness in an earlier post, but recently I received another question regarding my opinions on homelessness and of the location of the Mustard Seed. This was also a question that was not asked at the forum for my particular group at the Electoral Forum last Wednesday night. For those of you who have had the opportunity to discuss this topic in person with me have heard, and as my response to a concerned resident of Medicine Hat, here is my response:
"Thank you for your question and as a business owner downtown and someone who lives downtown, I recognize the concerns created from our "homeless" population. Coming from Red Deer as well, I saw its downtown become empty and void of business due to the fear and concerns of the homeless population, to the point where the homeless population "took over" the downtown and made it their own. The city, in a way, let the downtown become a place that actually was scary to go to.
The concern of "homelessness" is multifaceted, but when I get asked this question, what most people are talking about is the "undesirable behaviour" or criminal behaviour often associated with the homeless population. So, to clarify, there are issues within homelessness that need addressing from a compassionate perspective, such as affordable or assisted housing, mental health supports, drug and addiction support and so on. Unfortunately, the agencies in the city work very hard but can only do so much. As well, these services are only for the homeless population that are ready and wanting to take advantage of them. These agencies are also restricted and limited by provincial and federal policy and decision (ex. Cutting of funding and support, and laws and bylaws that make things more challenging for our judicial system).
So I come back to "what solutions can we find to help alleviate and minimize the social disorder and undesirable (usually criminal) behaviour."
As a business owner downtown, and the lead/chair of the Downtown Voice, one of our priorities is to make our area active, busy and thriving. For example, when it is very busy downtown, although the homeless population is still present, we do not see or experience the criminal or undesirable behaviour. However, when we start talking fear "don't come downtown because of the homeless, and it's scary", and we give into that fear, we create a situation like Red Deer, where the general community stops coming downtown, the homeless population starts to see it as their place and feel comfortable being disorderly. We create a space for them to live in their misery, and this isn't good for them either.
So the solution I have proposed to our downtown businesses and to the city is to not give into fear, create a vibrant and active area (the downtown in this case) that makes it difficult for our homeless population to feel comfortable being disorderly. Again, take any busy day downtown and you do not see disorderly behaviour. When the streets are empty, all of that disorder starts to come out.
This not only helps our community but it helps the homeless community as well, as they have the opportunity to be part of what a healthy society looks like. Often they can start to learn how to more appropriately find their place, as many times, these people are lacking connection and a positive model to fit into. It also creates a greater opportunity for those homeless, to access the services and help that they may be ready to access. The criminals on the other hand, no longer see it as a place to openly do criminal behaviour, or the homeless that act out of frustration, feel less comfortable acting out.
With that being said, how do we address the issue of a Mustard Seed, Food bank or other service that brings the homeless population to a neighborhood. Living just above the old Food Bank, and beside St. Barnabas church (who provides meals for the homeless every Saturday), I experience the concerns. I experience first hand that once the church members have left and the crowds of homeless are still present, and the streets and parkade are quiet of any other activity, we as residents are left in the midst of the undesirable behaviours, yelling, fighting, graffiti, destruction of property, vandalism, open drug use and so on.
Therefore, in choosing sites for places like the Mustard Seed, we need to be very careful and thoughtful of where to locate them. We need to address issues like, what locations will best serve the homeless and allow the Mustard Seed (and places like it) to be most effective, but also find strategies to put in place to minimize the negative, undesirable effects that often come with the homeless population. For example, living where I do, I appreciate it when the police are able to take the time to patrol and even park in our area before and after the meal being served on Saturday's. When they aren't there, as they often have other places to be, it can get quite disorderly. Also, to look at locations where there will be the least impact on the neighboring community. And again, I say the "least impact", as I recognize that no matter what area of the city these services are placed, there will be an impact: Whether that be residential or business. Therefore, whatever area has to take on that challenge, it is important to support them. For example, if a service such as the Mustard Seed was to be close to the downtown, it is important that the people of the city help the downtown stay vibrant, active and thriving (like I mentioned above), to help in a positive way, to help maintain a healthy downtown, knowing that, with their involvement, just by shopping and dining and being present, helps not only the downtown businesses but helps reduce the undesirable behaviour we are concerned about. It would be important to have greater police presence, like our downtown police unit, if for at the very least to help everyone feel more safe, and as a visible reminder to those who engage in criminal behaviour.
I'm only using the downtown as an example, as this is where I live and work, but wherever these services and agencies are finally located, we need to find strategies to help support those neighborhoods. I think for those areas of the community that do not have to take on that responsibility, it should be a big incentive for them to say "thank you for taking that on, and we will support you however best we can".
Sorry for the very long response, and I hope I have answered your question. I do not have all of the answers or solutions, but I am very passionate about finding positive solutions that address as many if not all of the concerns in the best possible way.
I am open to hearing further suggestions, or if you have concerns that I have not addressed in my response. I would love to hear them.
Thank you again for reaching out, and if I am voted in I will continue to listen to the concerns of the community and work hard at finding solutions that best serve our city."